Well, we’ve reached the final book of the Trei Asar: Malachi!
And with this blog, we’re bringing our journey through the twelve “minor” prophets to a close. It’s been a great journey with you! And we have a great way to end it this week with Malachi! Now, we have no personal information in the text about Malachi. However, his name itself is intriguing and has inspired some debate about his identity in Jewish tradition.
The name “Malachi” means “my messenger.” And the Hebrew word malach can also mean “angel,” which makes sense since an angel is a messenger of God. So there is some debate in Jewish tradition about whether Malachi is a formal name or whether it expresses the role of the writer as a messenger of God.
According to some in Jewish tradition, Malachi is actually Ezra. The rationale is that they seem to have some similar concerns, including issues related to intermarriage among the priests. This theory is found in the Gemara (which is part of the Talmud), and Rashi also notes it, although he doesn’t necessarily argue for it.
There’s another opinion that Malachi is Mordechai from the book of Esther, which, from a time standpoint, could potentially work.
The majority opinion among Chazal (the Sages), though, is that Malachi was his own person.
Now, as far as the time period goes, it’s generally agreed that Malachi was writing a generation or two after Haggai and Zechariah. Remember, those two neviim were writing to the first wave of exiles who had returned to Israel from Babylon. And it was that generation, under the leadership of Zerubbabel and Joshua, that rebuilt the Second Temple. It’s possible that Malachi came later because his concerns assume that the Temple and priesthood had been up and running (again) for a while. Specifically, enough time had passed that corruption had reemerged within the priesthood.
And this corruption is central to Malachi’s concern.
Although a precise date is difficult to determine, a date in the early 400s BCE seems reasonable. So we’re probably talking about somewhere between 50 and 100 years after Haggai and Zechariah. Now, moving to the text, the framework of Malachi is quite unique.
Basically, the flow of the book is a dialogue where “God says this,” but “Israel says that.” And that’s how the prophet begins in the very first breath!
In Malachi 1:2, HaShem says:
“I have loved you,” says the Lord. But you say, “How have you loved us?”
Now, I think the thinking behind Israel’s response is something like this:
“Look, God…You allowed the First Temple to be destroyed. We were in Babylon for seventy years. Now we’ve been back home for a while, and things still aren’t that great here. YOU CALL THAT LOVE?”
Well, God responds by pointing to what happened to Esau, or Edom, and reminding Israel that He has protected them from their enemies and will continue to do so. And verse 5 suggests that the people acknowledge God’s response, declaring, “Great is the Lord beyond the border of Israel!” But in light of His affirmation of His love for Israel, God now has a complaint.
In verses 6-14, HaShem is saying that He doesn’t feel His love is being reciprocated. Namely, God is quite upset with the cohanim (priests) and the entire manner in which the sacrificial system is being conducted.
As we’ve noted, the Beit HaMikdash (Temple) has been rebuilt for some time. The priests have been doing their thing, and sacrifices are being brought. But the problem is basically that the Jewish people are being “cheap” with the sacrifices! According to the Torah, animals brought to the altar were to be unblemished. But in Malachi 1:8, God says:
“When you offer blind animals in sacrifice, is that not evil? And when you offer those that are lame or sick, is that not evil? Present that to your governor; will he accept you or show you favor?”
So God is basically saying, “Don’t expect Me to show you favor if this is how you’re going to serve Me.”
In fact, He goes on in verse 10 to say, in hyperbolic fashion, that He wishes someone would just shut the Temple doors and close the whole operation!
Now, moving on to chapter 2, Malachi fixes his attention more directly on the cohanim. And as we’ve seen at other points in the Trei Asar, God is not happy with the priests.
The people certainly had their part in bringing these subpar sacrifices in the first place. But it was the job of the priests to “guard the gate,” if you will, and keep unfit sacrifices from being slaughtered. And they weren’t doing that. In Malachi 2:7-8, HaShem says:
“For the lips of a priest should guard knowledge, and people should seek instruction from his mouth, for he is the messenger of the Lord of hosts. But you have turned aside from the way. You have caused many to stumble by your instruction.”
And verse 9 adds that the priests were showing “partiality” in their instruction.
Now, the sacrifices, when done properly, were supposed to bring life and peace. They were a means of cleansing the altar so God’s presence could dwell in the midst of Israel. And the sacrifices were a way for people to draw near to God. But all of this was being corrupted by the priests, who were also guilty of some kind of corrupt teaching involving partiality.
So what exactly was this partiality? Well, the prophet doesn’t specify. But various interpreters understand this as referring to converts to Judaism. And that idea makes some sense in light of verse 10, which says:
“Have we not all one Father? Has not one God created us?”
Perhaps this is a defense of converts as deserving equal treatment. And I think Malachi may be highlighting some irony here. On the one hand, converts to Judaism may have been getting snubbed. And on the other hand, Malachi goes on to condemn Judah for marrying foreign wives who were worshiping other gods. So if this theory is correct, the priests were snubbing converts to Judaism while marrying pagan Gentiles who had not converted!
Now, this raises an important question for us.
What kind of partiality in religious circles today might make HaShem angry?
Well, specifically in a Messianic Jewish context, I think when Gentiles are made to feel like second-class members, that’s a huge problem. It’s one thing to celebrate and protect the unique roles of Jews and Gentiles in Messianic Judaism, which is something we can make a biblical case for. But it’s another thing to have a religious culture that minimizes the equality of Jews and Gentiles.
A central Messianic reality is that “in Messiah,” Jews and Gentiles are given equal status while their identities remain distinct. If that is lost or blurred, then Messianic and Kingdom realities are lost and blurred.
Well, there are two more texts we need to look at before we finish Malachi.
First, let’s look at Malachi 3:1-4. Here, HaShem speaks about sending His messenger to prepare the way before Him. And then we read:
“And the Lord whom you seek will suddenly come to his temple.”
The passage goes on to describe this coming figure as a refiner who will purify the sons of Levi so that they can once again bring righteous offerings to HaShem. Now, this is generally understood as a Messianic passage. And there’s so much we could say about it. But I want to highlight one important point.
What does this text indicate about the relationship between the Messiah and the Temple sacrifices in the Messianic era?
Is there harmony here or disharmony? Well, there is perfect harmony!
So it’s not the Messianic era unless there is compatibility between the Messiah and the Temple sacrifices, contrary to many theologies.
Lastly, let’s land the plane where Malachi does.
He closes his sefer with these words in Malachi 4:4-6:
“Remember the law of my servant Moses, the statutes and rules that I commanded him at Horeb for all Israel.”
And then:
“Behold, I will send you Elijah the prophet before the great and awesome day of the Lord comes. And he will turn the hearts of fathers to their children and the hearts of children to their fathers.”
So as the final prophet in the Tanach/Old Testament, what does HaShem leave us with?
Two things.
Remember the Torah.
And be on the lookout for Eliyahu (Elijah), who will usher in the final age.
Well, I hope you’ve enjoyed this eighteen-part series on the Trei Asar!
I’ve thoroughly enjoyed it!
And a major takeaway is the continual emphasis from the prophets on the power of teshuvah and the importance of prioritizing kindness, empathy, and mercy. If these things are missing from our devotion to HaShem and Yeshua, then we are way off.
May HaShem help us walk in the ways of the prophets, especially during these times, by representing the values they were so passionate about seeing normalized in their generation and ours.
"It’s interesting that there is a significance behind all the Hebrew letters and numbers. I found especially interesting the significance of the number 3 - the Trinity, Jesus rose on the 3rd day, the three languages of the Bible, etc. I can hardly wait to share with my Tribe."
What is Fusion with Rabbi Jason?
It is in looking back at what God has done that we can see forward to His future plans for us. “For I know the plans I have for you,’ declares the Lord, plans to prosper you and not to harm you, plans to give you hope and a future” Jer 29:11.
At Fusion Global with Rabbi Jason Sobel, we want to add definition to your faith as we restore the lost connection to our ancient roots and rediscover our forgotten inheritance.